OCALA, Fl. (352 Today) – Law enforcement agencies in Marion County are turning to the public for assistance in locating some of the area’s most elusive fugitives. Crime Stoppers of Marion County has released its updated Top 10 Most Wanted list, featuring individuals wanted for serious crimes including aggravated assault, battery on law enforcement officers, felony drug charges, theft, and burglary. These suspects are believed to be actively evading arrest, and authorities are urging residents to remain vigilant and report any information that could help bring them into custody. Anonymous tips that lead to an arrest may be eligible for a cash reward of up to $1,000.
Below are the current fugitives on the list as of August 5, 2025:
Cianna Jay Gutbrod: DOB 8/5/1992 – Battery on law enforcement/firefighter/EMS – Felony VOP
Kimberly Lashawn Montgomery: DOB 07‑18‑1983 – Driving under the influence – Felony VOP
Bryan Jennings Winters: DOB 02‑08‑1982 – Possession of methamphetamine, marijuana, drug paraphernalia – Felony VOP
John Wesley Tidwell: DOB 04‑01‑1970 – Cocaine possession – Felony VOP
Avery Gerrard Patterson: DOB 08‑27‑1971 – Aggravated battery with intent to harm – Felony VOP
Daniel Dwayne Reese: DOB 10‑22‑1986 – Second-degree battery by strangulation – Felony warrant
Theresa Marie Gallo: DOB 06‑16‑1986 – Petit theft (third conviction) – Felony VOP
Shawnice Nichole Slaughter: DOB 10‑22‑1992 – Possession of controlled substances, grand theft over $750 – Felony VOP
Buddy Ray Mallory: DOB 11‑25‑1979 – Aggravated assault with deadly weapon, firearm discharge in public – Felony bench warrant
Anthony Arenas: DOB 03‑08‑1984 – Grand theft over $750, burglary of a conveyance – Felony VOP
How to Help
Crime Stoppers is urging anyone with information about these individuals to come forward. Citizens can submit tips anonymously by calling (352) 368-STOP (7867) or by visiting ocalacrimestoppers.com. Tipsters do not need to reveal their identity to be eligible for a cash reward of up to $1,000.
Officials remind the public not to attempt to apprehend any of these individuals, as many are considered dangerous. Instead, contact law enforcement or Crime Stoppers directly.
About Crime Stoppers
Crime Stoppers of Marion County is a community-based program that empowers citizens to anonymously report information about crimes. The program partners with law enforcement, the media, and the public to help solve cases and prevent future criminal activity. Tipsters remain completely anonymous and may be eligible for a cash reward if their information leads to an arrest or recovery of stolen property or narcotics.
To view updated lists and photos of all most wanted suspects, visit the Crime Stoppers website at ocalacrimestoppers.com.